From The Rink: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
New Blog: Voodoo Five for South Florida Bulls Fans!

Leafs call foul over Roberts deal

Apparently the Toronto Maple Leafs were none too pleased with the fact the Florida Panthers chose to deal Gary Roberts to Pittsburgh rather than his former team, something the local media picked up on quickly yesterday after talking to a seething GM John Ferguson.

Today, the Panthers are saying there was no spite intended with the deal and that they, in fact, simply liked the player (Noah Welch) the Penguins were offering better than the package of Brendan Bell and a second- and fourth-round pick.

Now, maybe neither Bell or Welch are going to be top-flight blueliners, but I would say their relative value is reasonably close — something that has been disputed by both the Maple Leafs and many in the media here — with Welch winning out due to his size and leadership abilities.

Welch may have went the NCAA route and captained the Harvard Crimson, but that's not all that uncommon for an American defensive prospect — and it doesn't mean he's not capable of playing a big role with the Panthers. Welch is a huge kid at 6 foot 4, 215 pounds, a guy who appears to move his feet pretty well for a big man and has an offensive side to his game (as noted by the 21 points in 25 games in the AHL this season). He was also an AHL all-star.

Welch was selected a round higher than Bell in the 2001 draft, and from all accounts, has really developed quicker than expected into a potential Top 4 NHL defenceman. Bell, meanwhile, caused a stir here in Toronto when he actually made the big club and served as a suitable injury replacement. His upside, in my opinion, is negligible (which is likely why he was dealt for Yanic Perreault yesterday).

The Panthers have really started to assemble quite the big, young defence core, with players like Jay Bouwmeester (6'4", 214), Bryan Allen (6'4", 220), Branislav Mezei (6'5", 235) and Alexei Semenov (6'6", 235), and I honestly can't understand why there's this goofy kerfuffle over them choosing Welch over Bell.

Is it really that hard to believe that a prospect from the NCAA that most people have never heard of (think 'the next Kevin Bieksa') is better than someone who plays for the Maple Leafs?

0 recs  |  Comment 0 comments

Story-email Email Printer Print

More from From The Rink

More on Lou's loophole

Feb 2007 by James Mirtle - 0 comments

The hockey dads hit the road

Feb 2007 by James Mirtle - 0 comments

30 years of Leafs photos

Jan 2007 by James Mirtle - 0 comments

Comments

Display:

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to SBN's blog on all things hockey

Start posting on From The Rink »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

Connect_with_facebook

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Small
SB Nation Survey + Chance to donate $500 to a charity of this community's choice
Nhl-and-food-network_small
There Will Be Blood?
Small
Ice Edge Holdings? I don`t think so!
Dave_hockey_pic_small
My Olympic Hockey Tournament Game Over Ramblings
Gary_bettman_bad_dreams_small
2010 U.S. v Canada = 1980 U.S. v Soviet Union? Why It Doesn't, and Why It Does
Small
Burke and a premeptive whine
Small
Ice edge out?
One_lindsay05_small
Getzlaf injured; Olympics in question?
Small
Lightning sale imminent-what about PHX?
Small
Dave Tippett for the Jack Adams award!

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Blog extras

SBNation.com Recent Stories

Eric Nystrom, left, and Mikael Backlund of the Calgary Flames celebrate a goal in the second period of a NHL hockey game March 19, 2010, in Calgary, Alberta. (AP)

Sharks Fizzle Out Again, Lose To Flames, 4-3

Photo link

An Interview With Sharks Prospect Jamie McGinn

Denver left winger Rhett Rakhshani (9) and Colorado College defenseman Nate Prosser (15) chase the puck into the corner during an NCAA college hockey game in Denver, Friday, March 5, 2010.

2010 Hobey Baker Award Finalists Announced

More from SBNation.com >


Bloggers-in-chief

Awkwardmarleau_small Mike Chen

Editors

Penguins_cup_08__small FrankD

Canes-country-logo_small Bob Harwood Waeghe

Cc_cory_small Cory Lavalette

Gabby_small Joe Fortunato

Moderator(s)

Calvin_small PPP

643c0d9c_small saskhab