How NHL Rule Changes Are Made
With all the talk of rule changes (especially hits to the head) coming out of the GM meetings down in Florida, I thought I'd give a quick primer on how the actual rule change process goes. It's always easy to blame Gary Bettman for something that's not working, but you can easily see that he's actually got very little to do with the process.
Step 1: GMs recommend rule changes.
This stems from meetings like the current GM gathering. Usually, the GMs break up into smaller groups to discuss various topics, then they reconvene to share ideas and then there's a motion to recommend a rule change. If a rule change is recommended, it gets elevated to the competition committee.
Step 2: Competition committee analyzes and makes recommendations.
Your current NHL competition committtee is made up of Ryan Miller, Jason Spezza, Jeff Halpern, Mathieu Schneider (who counts even though he doesn't skate a regular NHL shift), and Brian Campbell. The committee goes over the GM recommendations, then makes their own set of recommendations about what to implement into the game.
Step 3: Board of Governors vote.
I've said quite a few times over my various blog incarnations that most of the blame regarding the negative aspects of the game should go to the Board of Governors rather than Gary Bettman, as the BoG decides the rules while Bettman works as negotiator and spokesperson. Here's another instance of it. Once the competition committee sends a rule change to the BoG, it's set for a vote. Now, the only instance where Bettman will actually come in on any vote is to act as a tiebreaker. Thus, even if the GMs recommend a rule change and the competition committee agrees with it, it can still be killed in the BoG.
0 recs |
6 comments
| Add comment
|
Comments
While I think I know what you were going for – its would not be correct to suggest that Bettman is without influence on these issues. The BOG, like any Board of Directors, is looking to its executives – Bettman, Daly, Campbell – for guidance on these competition issues, and, if the BOG is smart, asking questions about how these changes will impact the game, and the NHL business.
Glen Sather is a Hockey Genius.
http://glensathersucks.com/
http://twitter.com/ThGeneralissimo
Oh, he’s definitely a driver in the conversation’s direction. He’s just not the all-evil overlord that some make him out to be. The BoG has the final say. I’m sure Bettman’s a smart guy, but I doubt anyone in the world would be able to control 30 stubborn billionaires into doing exactly what he wants.
Enforcement
Sure, it could be a rule, but it’ll still probably be haphazardly enforced with Colin Campbell doing his best to dish out nonsensical suspensions/fines to players on a case by case basis.
Please NBC, Fire Milbury, Hire Roenick Full time!!!
I suspect issues don’t make it to the agenda, let alone to a vote, unless there’s a certainty that it shall be resolved in a manner to the league’s liking. Bettman may not actually vote on these issues, as he often reminds listeners of the NHL Hour, but he likely holds plenty of power in the process.
MG
From what I can tell, the only place he holds power is at the BoG table. The managers and players run things pretty independently of the NHL head office. You hear the proposals Colin Campbell brings (remember big/curved nets?) and the managers often laugh him out of the meeting. Heck, even the managers themselves propose wacky things… Gainey suggested a ban on shot blocking by forwards to increase offence.
Hockey blogging can't get any flatter.
Something to say? Choose one of these options to log in.
On Facebook? Use Connect to join SB Nation. Share insights with fans and friends.- » Create a new SB Nation account
- » Already registered with SB Nation? Log in!

by 















